Add the lip balm duo — get FREE shipping
Superfruit Sterols Lip Balm
Antioxidant packed Açaí + Pomegranate Sterols lip balms
“The best lip balm you’ll ever try. We guarantee it.”★★★★★
I've been through more tallow balms than I'd like to admit. Only one actually made a difference.
Every balm on this list was used daily for at least three weeks. I scored them on four things:
TALLOWED TRUTH
Most Hyped on Social Media
All over social media right now. Five clean ingredients, no fillers. Texture is dense and needs warming before applying and noticeably heavier than anything bison-based.
Hydration is solid and the jar lasts. But like most basic beef tallow balms, it moisturizes and that's it. No visible change in tone or texture after three weeks.
Try It Here
thetallowedruth.com
ANCESTRAL COSMETICS
Best Clean Ingredient List
Irish grass-fed beef tallow, raw honey, beeswax, essential oils. Genuinely short ingredient list. Spreads easy and hydration lasts. But the scent is strong very herbal, patchouli-heavy. Not for everyone.
Good basic option if scent doesn't bother you. Moisture only, no visible results beyond that.
Try It Here
ancestralcosmetics.com
#3 — PRIMALLY PURE
Most Popular
Probably the most well-known tallow brand.
Beef tallow, olive oil, emu oil, beeswax, some lavender and tea tree. It's thick, thicker than I expected. Takes a while to sink in.
I ended up using it only at night because it felt heavy under sunscreen in the morning.
For basic hydration it's solid. Dry patches cleared up, redness calmed within a week.
But no change in tone, texture, or lines. It's doing one job — moisture — and doing it fine.
What I love:
What I don't:
Try It Here
primallypure.com
#2 — GRAZLY
Best Bison on a Budget
Tried this because it's bison tallow and I wanted to compare.
The Manuka honey is a nice touch and the whipped texture is light and easy to apply. Because it's bison, it does absorb faster than the beef tallow balms on this list.
But it's whipped and that means a 2oz jar is partly air. It goes faster than it should. And while the bison base is nice, there's nothing else in it beyond tallow and honey.
Hydration is good. No visible change in tone or texture after three weeks though.
It proved to me that the tallow source alone isn't the whole story.
What I love:
What I don't:
Try It Here
grazly.ca
#1 — PLAIN RITUAL
Best Overall · Best Results
This is the one that ended my search.
It absorbs instantly, no film, no residue, nothing sitting on top.
Two weeks in, my skin tone started evening out.
I noticed an actual glow building, the kind I'd given up expecting from a tallow balm.
The fine lines around my eyes softened.
That caught me off guard because nothing else on this list came close to doing that.
They use neroli essential oil and I can barely smell the tallow. If scent has ever been a dealbreaker, this solves it.
Every other balm I tested moisturized. This one actually changed how my skin looks.
What I love:
What I don't:
Try It Here
plainritual.com
Two things became clear.
Bison tallow absorbs faster. Feels lighter. You notice it first use.
But that alone didn't change my skin. Grazly proved it. Great base. Three weeks later — just moisturized.
Plain Ritual was different.
Glow came back. Skin evened out. Lines softened.
I think it's what they add alongside the tallow.
Everything else on this list? Just moisture.
| Plain Ritual | Grazly | Primally Pure | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tallow source | Bison | Bison | Beef |
| Absorption | ★★★★★★★★★★ | ★★★★★★★★★★ | ★★★★★★★★★★ |
| Results beyond moisture | Yes | No | No |
| Overall | ★★★★★★★★★★ | ★★★★★★★★★★ | ★★★★★★★★★★ |
Swipe to see all ratings
If you've been cycling through tallow balms that all do the same thing, moisturize but never actually change anything, this is the one that changed it for me.
I paid full price for mine months ago. Right now they're running an Easter sale so you'd get a better deal than I did.
Jessica Reyes
Just got mine, so excited to try it!
Steph Boudreau
waited way too long to try this tbh. I was so loyal to my etsy tallow lady but this is just better 😭
Plain Ritual
Welcome! Glad to have you with us 😊
Nicole Kowalsk
I'm interested but $33 for 1oz feels steep when grazly is $36 for 2oz… someone convince me lol
Chelsea Ariew
I got three on sale for $78 and just finished my first one after six weeks, so worth it.
Megan Lawson
ok but is bison tallow actually that different from beef?? I've been using the stuff from my local farm and idk if I need to switch
Danielle Sandoval
@Megan Lawson yes girl day & night. I thought the same thing like how different can it really be but this is like… actually lightweight?? it sinks in right away and doesn't leave that film. I can't go back to beef tallow now honestly
Tyler Kerrigan
Does it work for eczema?
Lisa M.
Yes! It's been amazing for my eczema actually
Natasha Okafor
Nobody asked but I have perioral dermatitis around my mouth and literally nothing has calmed it down. not cerave not vanicream not the prescription cream my derm gave me. I've been using this for like 3 weeks and it's almost completely gone??
Karen Mitchell
@Ashley Whitmore this is what I was talking about
Amanda Thornton
my skin GLOWS. like I stopped wearing foundation. I'm shooketh
Priya Nair
Bought one for me and my mom 💖